The New York Yankees star has struggled with numerous injuries since joining the team.
August 12, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; New York Yankees designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton (27) reacts after striking out against the Chicago White Sox in the fourth inning at Guaranteed Rate Field. / Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports
When the New York Yankees acquired Giancarlo Stanton, it was considered one of the most significant moves in Major League Baseball. The right-handed power hitter was among the league’s elite, coming off a season in which he earned his first and only MVP award.
With five All-Star selections, an MVP award, two Silver Slugger titles, and other accolades, Stanton has built a Hall of Fame-worthy career. He currently has 422 home runs, and reaching 500 would greatly enhance his chances of induction into Cooperstown.
His statistics are impressive, and despite occasional struggles with the Yankees, few players in baseball over the past decade have matched his production. However, Stanton’s time with New York has been marked by injuries and performance that hasn’t lived up to his contract. With a $325 million deal, high-level performance is not just expected but essential given the financial commitment. Consequently, Kerry Miller of Bleacher Report included him on the “all-overpaid” MLB team.
The New York Yankees’ acquisition of Giancarlo Stanton was once seen as one of Major League Baseball’s biggest signings. The right-handed slugger, coming off an MVP season, was among the game’s top hitters. With five All-Star selections, an MVP award, two Silver Slugger titles, and 422 career home runs, he seemed destined for Cooperstown if he reaches 500 home runs.
Despite his impressive career numbers, Stanton has faced frequent injuries and inconsistent performance with the Yankees. His $325 million contract demands high-level performance, which has not always been met. As a result, Kerry Miller of Bleacher Report included him in the “all-overpaid” MLB team.
Miller noted that while Stanton’s recent batting average (.241) and OPS (.780) might seem decent in the context of the Yankees’ struggling lineup, his performance over the past two seasons (.202 AVG, .729 OPS) has been underwhelming. Stanton’s contributions have been vital when he is healthy; the Yankees have a strong record when he drives in runs, but they struggled during his extended time on the injured list. If not for his injury issues, Stanton might have been a much more effective player for the Yankees.
When the New York Yankees have faced offensive struggles in the postseason, Giancarlo Stanton has been one of the few players to deliver significantly. In his postseason tenure with the Yankees, he has a line of .260/.327/.636, with 11 home runs and 24 RBIs over 96 at-bats.
Going forward, his health will be crucial. With several years remaining on his contract and a team option for 2028, the Yankees’ options are limited. Their best hope is that he can remain healthy and contribute consistently.
Leave a Reply